Forensic Engineering: Where Technical Investigation Meets Legal Standards
Back to Blog
Forensic EngineeringRoot Cause AnalysisExpert TestimonyInvestigation

Forensic Engineering: Where Technical Investigation Meets Legal Standards

TKO Research Team10 min read

When systems fail, products malfunction, or accidents occur, the question isn't just "what happened?"—it's "why did it happen?" and "who is responsible?" Forensic engineering provides the technical rigor and legal admissibility needed to answer these questions definitively. At TKOResearch, we bring government-grade investigative tradecraft to forensic engineering, combining digital forensics, physical analysis, and materials science to uncover root causes and establish liability.

What is Forensic Engineering?

Forensic engineering applies engineering principles and scientific methods to investigate failures, accidents, and disputes. It's the discipline that determines:

  • Root cause: The fundamental reason a failure occurred
  • Proximate cause: The immediate trigger of the incident
  • Contributing factors: Conditions that enabled or exacerbated the failure
  • Liability: Who bears responsibility for the failure
  • Prevention: How similar failures can be avoided

Unlike routine failure analysis, forensic engineering operates within legal and regulatory frameworks, producing findings that can withstand courtroom scrutiny and expert examination.

The TKOResearch Approach: Cyber-Physical Integration

Traditional forensic engineering often focuses purely on mechanical or structural failures. Our unique approach integrates:

Digital Forensics

Modern systems are controlled by software and produce digital evidence:

  • Embedded system analysis and firmware examination
  • Control system log analysis
  • Network communication forensics
  • IoT device data extraction
  • Software defect and vulnerability analysis

Physical Analysis

Material and structural investigation revealing physical evidence:

  • Component failure analysis
  • Material defects and degradation
  • Manufacturing quality issues
  • Environmental stress factors
  • Wear pattern analysis

Laboratory Capabilities

Our OASIS Analytical Framework provides comprehensive materials analysis:

  • Microscopy and imaging
  • Chemical composition analysis
  • Stress and fatigue testing
  • Failure mode replication
  • Counterfeit detection

This cyber-physical nexus reveals insights impossible with siloed approaches.

Core Forensic Engineering Services

Product Liability Investigations

When products fail causing injury or damage:

Consumer Products: Electronics, appliances, and devices

  • Design defect analysis
  • Manufacturing defect identification
  • Failure to warn assessment
  • Regulatory compliance verification

Industrial Equipment: Machinery and tools

  • Safety system failure analysis
  • Operator interface defects
  • Maintenance requirement adequacy
  • Industry standard compliance

Fire and Explosion Investigation

Technical analysis determining origin and cause:

Electrical Fire Analysis

  • Circuit failure identification
  • Overcurrent and fault analysis
  • Wiring defect examination
  • Device malfunction determination

Battery and Energy Storage Failures

  • Thermal runaway analysis
  • Manufacturing defect identification
  • Abuse or misuse detection
  • Design inadequacy assessment

Construction and Building Forensics

Investigating structural failures and defects:

Structural Failures

  • Load analysis and stress calculation
  • Material specification verification
  • Construction quality assessment
  • Design adequacy evaluation

Water Intrusion and Damage

  • Failure mechanism identification
  • Building envelope analysis
  • System design review
  • Maintenance and workmanship evaluation

Cyber-Physical System Failures

Where digital meets physical:

Industrial Control Systems

  • SCADA system failure analysis
  • PLC programming defects
  • Network security compromises
  • Human-machine interface issues

Automotive Systems

  • Electronic control unit (ECU) analysis
  • CAN bus communication forensics
  • Sensor and actuator failures
  • Software defect identification

IoT and Smart Devices

  • Connected device failure analysis
  • Cloud service reliability issues
  • Security vulnerability exploitation
  • Firmware and software defects

Real-World Applications

Insurance Subrogation

Recovering losses by establishing third-party liability:

Subrogation Example: A commercial building fire

  • Digital forensics of fire alarm and sprinkler systems
  • Electrical system failure analysis
  • Materials testing of ignition source
  • Maintenance record review
  • Expert determination of responsible party
  • Result: $2.3M subrogation recovery for carrier

Product Recall Support

Determining scope and cause of product failures:

Recall Investigation: Battery-powered tool failures

  • Field failure analysis of returned products
  • Manufacturing process review
  • Design verification and testing
  • Root cause identification
  • Recommendation for recall scope and remediation
  • Result: Targeted recall reducing liability while maintaining customer safety

Construction Defect Litigation

Supporting claims or defense in construction disputes:

Construction Case: Water intrusion in residential development

  • Building envelope forensics
  • Material specification review
  • Installation workmanship assessment
  • Design adequacy evaluation
  • Apportionment of responsibility among contractors
  • Result: Clear liability determination enabling settlement

Intellectual Property Disputes

Technical analysis in patent and trade secret cases:

IP Investigation: Trade secret theft allegation

  • Digital forensics revealing data exfiltration
  • Product tear-down and reverse engineering
  • Design comparison and similarity analysis
  • Manufacturing process examination
  • Result: Clear evidence of misappropriation supporting $5M+ settlement

Daubert-Compliant Methodology

All TKOResearch forensic engineering follows the Daubert standard for scientific evidence:

1. Testability

Hypotheses can be and have been tested using scientific methods

2. Peer Review

Methods are published and accepted in relevant scientific communities

3. Known Error Rates

Techniques have documented accuracy and reliability

4. Standards and Controls

Following established industry standards and best practices

5. General Acceptance

Methods are generally accepted in relevant scientific fields

This rigor ensures our findings are admissible in federal and state courts.

The Investigation Process

Phase 1: Evidence Preservation

  • Scene documentation and photography
  • Evidence collection with chain-of-custody
  • Digital data preservation
  • Environmental condition recording

Phase 2: Initial Assessment

  • Preliminary failure analysis
  • Hypothesis development
  • Investigation scope determination
  • Resource allocation planning

Phase 3: Technical Investigation

  • Detailed examination and testing
  • Digital forensics and data analysis
  • Materials analysis and laboratory testing
  • Expert consultation as needed

Phase 4: Root Cause Determination

  • Hypothesis validation or rejection
  • Contributing factor identification
  • Alternative explanation elimination
  • Confidence level assessment

Phase 5: Reporting and Testimony

  • Comprehensive technical report
  • Executive summary for decision-makers
  • Visual aids and demonstrative evidence
  • Deposition and trial testimony as needed

Expert Testimony and Litigation Support

Our forensic engineering experts provide:

Deposition Testimony

  • Clear explanation of technical findings
  • Defense of methodology under questioning
  • Professional demeanor under adversarial examination

Trial Testimony

  • Jury-friendly explanation of complex concepts
  • Visual demonstrations and exhibits
  • Cross-examination preparation and response
  • Daubert challenge defense

Report Preparation

  • Federal Rules of Civil Procedure compliance
  • Clear methodology documentation
  • Comprehensive findings presentation
  • Alternative hypothesis consideration

Unique Value Propositions

1. Cyber-Physical Integration

Unlike traditional forensic engineers focused solely on mechanical failures, we seamlessly integrate digital forensics with physical analysis—critical for modern systems where software controls hardware.

2. Government-Grade Tradecraft

Nearly two decades of intelligence community experience applied to failure investigation. We investigate systems like nation-state adversaries analyze targets—comprehensively and rigorously.

3. Rapid Turnaround

48-72 hour preliminary findings for time-critical decisions, with comprehensive reports following in 2-3 weeks. Fast doesn't mean superficial—it means efficient and focused.

4. Laboratory Capabilities

In-house materials analysis through our OASIS Analytical Framework eliminates third-party delays and maintains evidence security.

5. Boutique Service Model

Principal-level expertise on every case. Direct access to our forensic director, not case managers or junior engineers.

When to Engage Forensic Engineering

Consider forensic engineering when:

  • High-stakes litigation requires expert testimony and technical analysis
  • Product liability claims need root cause determination
  • Insurance subrogation seeks third-party liability identification
  • Regulatory investigations demand scientific rigor and documentation
  • Internal investigations require independent expert validation
  • Settlement negotiations need authoritative technical opinions

Getting Started

Whether you're pursuing subrogation, defending a product liability claim, or need expert testimony in complex litigation, TKOResearch's forensic engineering expertise provides the technical rigor and legal admissibility you need.

For immediate consultation: Secure Intake Line at 445-895-1790
For confidential inquiries: Signal at KevinBytes.42

Learn more:


TKOResearch: Where engineering rigor meets forensic science. From digital evidence to material failure, we investigate the complete system.

View All Articles
Share this article